Pests

Onion thrips pressure in 2028: monitoring, thresholds and control

Thrips tabaci populations are running above average across eastern England this spring. How to monitor effectively, when to act and what products remain available.

2028 thrips situation overview

Onion thrips (Thrips tabaci) monitoring across eastern England onion-growing areas has recorded counts significantly above the five-year average for the first half of April 2028. The warm, dry conditions following a mild winter have created ideal conditions for early-season population build-up, with some growers reporting threshold-level infestations within three weeks of crop emergence.

Thrips is typically more of a late-spring and summer pest in UK onions, but the 2028 season is tracking earlier than usual. Growers drilling in March and early April face the highest immediate risk — young, actively growing plants are the most susceptible to thrips feeding damage, which creates permanent leaf scarring that affects marketable quality.

Available insecticide products and resistance management

ProductMode of actionActivityResistance statusKey notes
Spinosad (Tracer) Spinosyn (IRAC Group 5) Good contact/ingested on larvae Low resistance reported UK IPM-compatible; low bee toxicity; 3-day harvest interval
Lambda-cyhalothrin Pyrethroid (Group 3A) Good knockdown adults Pyrethroid resistance widespread Harmful to beneficials; use as rescue only
Acetamiprid (Gazelle) Neonicotinoid (Group 4A) Systemic; adults and larvae Monitor — limited data UK thrips Check approval status for onions; harvest interval 7d
Sulfoxaflor (Closer) Sulfoximine (Group 4C) Systemic; adults and larvae Low cross-resistance to Group 4A Bee risk — do not apply to flowering weeds; check label
Abamectin (Dynamec) Avermectin (Group 6) Contact + ingested; larvae Low resistance concern UK Effective on mite complex too; observe pre-harvest interval

Monitoring and action thresholds

Twice-weekly scouting is essential during warm, dry spring conditions. Examine at least 50 plants per field (5 plants at 10 sampling locations), counting adults and larvae directly on leaves and by shaking onto white paper. The commonly applied threshold of 5–10 thrips per leaf triggers treatment consideration, but decisions should factor in: crop growth stage, weather forecast (a forecast of rain may suppress populations without chemical intervention), remaining approved chemical options, and proximity to harvest.

For integrated pest management, see the onion weed and pest management guide and the onion agronomy guide. The stomatal conductance glossary entry explains why thrips-damaged leaves — with disrupted stomatal function from feeding damage — lose the ability to regulate water loss effectively.

Agronomic context: thrips and onion quality

Thrips damage has two distinct effects on marketable quality: (1) silvery scarring of the outer scale leaves reduces cosmetic quality for fresh market packs; (2) severe infestations during bulbing can reduce bulb size through photosynthetic area loss. For processing onions where skin appearance is less critical, the economic threshold may be somewhat higher — but both segments share the risk of thrips acting as a vector for iris yellow spot virus (IYSV), which causes straw-coloured spindle-shaped lesions and can cause significant yield loss in susceptible seasons.

Frequently asked questions

How do I identify thrips damage on onions and distinguish it from other causes?
Thrips tabaci (onion thrips) feeding causes characteristic silver-grey streaking and stippling on leaf surfaces — the result of cell content removal and air infiltrating the damaged cells. Severe infestations cause distortion of young leaves and silvery discolouration across the entire canopy. Distinguishing thrips damage from: (1) Downy mildew — downy mildew shows grey-purple sporulation on the abaxial (lower) leaf surface, not silveriness; affected tissue eventually collapses; (2) Botrytis leaf blight — distinct white lesions with green halos; (3) White tip / Phytoplasma — distinct tip bleaching without the silvery sheen. To confirm thrips, shake leaves over white paper — adults and larvae (pale yellow, elongate, 1–1.5 mm) will fall onto the surface. See the onion agronomy guide for integrated crop management context.
What is the economic threshold for thrips in onions and how should I scout?
The commonly used economic threshold for onion thrips in UK and European crops is 5–10 thrips per leaf or 30 thrips per plant, depending on growth stage and market. Younger, actively growing crops (before bulbing) are more sensitive to thrips damage because scarring affects the commercial leaf tissue. Once bulbing is underway and the outer scale leaves are forming, populations can be higher before affecting marketable quality. Scouting method: examine 5 plants per field location at 10 locations (50 plants total) at each assessment, counting adults and larvae per leaf. Scout twice weekly in warm, dry weather (above 25°C) when populations can treble in 3–4 days. See the onion weed and pest management guide for the full integrated pest management framework.
Why are thrips populations higher in 2028 than recent years?
The above-average thrips pressure in spring 2028 is linked to: (1) Mild 2027–28 winter — thrips overwinter as adults in plant debris and soil; mild winters result in higher overwintering survival and earlier spring activity; (2) Dry spring — hot, dry conditions in March–April 2028 are highly favourable for thrips reproduction (development time shortens at high temperatures); (3) Reduced predator populations — early dry weather also reduces populations of predatory Orius bugs and predatory mites that naturally suppress thrips. The combination of a warm winter survivor pool, fast spring reproduction and reduced biological control creates the conditions for early-season population explosions. Crop Monitor UK ↗ is reporting the highest April thrips counts since 2022 in eastern England onion-growing areas.
Can I use biological controls for thrips in field-grown onions?
Biological control options are more limited in field onions than in protected cropping environments. The predatory bug Orius laevigatus (pirate bug) is a natural enemy of thrips and can establish in field crops with suitable habitat — maintaining wildflower margins and reducing broad-spectrum insecticide use encourages Orius populations. Amblyseius cucumeris (predatory mite) can be applied as a field biological at early crop stages but establishment is difficult in drying onion leaf conditions. The most effective field IPM approach is conservation biological control: avoiding pyrethroid applications except as a last resort, rotating to spinosad or sulfoxaflor (which have lower impact on natural enemies), and maintaining field margins with beneficial insect habitat. The UK Pesticide Guide ↗ lists currently approved products.
What resistance concerns exist for thrips insecticides in the UK?
Pyrethroid resistance in Thrips tabaci is well-documented internationally and increasingly concerns UK advisers. The mechanism is primarily metabolic (increased cytochrome P450 detoxification) and target-site (voltage-gated sodium channel mutations). Operationally, this means lambda-cyhalothrin and other pyrethroids may give inconsistent control in populations that have been repeatedly exposed. The IRAC (Insecticide Resistance Action Committee) mode of action rotation principle is critical: rotate between IRAC Groups 5 (spinosad), 4A (neonicotinoids), 4C (sulfoximines) and 6 (abamectin) rather than relying on any single group. Never use the same IRAC group in consecutive applications within a season. Check the IRAC mode of action classification ↗ before programme design.