The carbon income landscape in 2028
Two parallel systems now offer payments for soil carbon improvement on UK arable farms: the government's Sustainable Farming Incentive (SFI), which pays for soil management actions regardless of measured carbon change, and voluntary carbon markets, which pay for verified increases in soil organic carbon stock.
The distinction matters. SFI is an action-based scheme — you receive payment for doing specific things (cover cropping, soil testing, reduced tillage) regardless of whether carbon stocks measurably increase. Voluntary markets are outcome-based — payment is contingent on verified carbon sequestration, which requires rigorous baseline sampling and repeat measurement. See the carbon farming payment rates article and the soil organic matter guide for background on soil carbon management.
2028 scheme comparison
Baseline soil sampling: the gateway to both schemes
Whether pursuing SFI SAM1 or voluntary carbon credits, a robust soil baseline is the starting point. For SFI, UKAS-accredited sampling at 0–15 cm and 15–30 cm is required, providing SOC, pH, P, K and Mg status. For voluntary carbon markets, bulk density measurement and sampling to 30 cm (some standards require 100 cm) are necessary to convert concentration data (% SOC) to stock estimates (t C/ha). Without bulk density, stock calculations are not possible and carbon credit applications will be rejected.
Composite sampling — typically 25 cores per 5-hectare zone — reduces analytical cost while maintaining statistical reliability. GPS-referenced sampling points allow repeat measurement at the same locations for change detection. See the soil sampling and testing guide and soil health carbon baseline article for methodology.
The stacking question
Receiving SFI payments and selling voluntary carbon credits from the same hectare — known as stacking — is one of the most contested issues in UK agricultural carbon policy. The government position is that SFI action payments do not constitute payment for carbon outcomes and therefore do not automatically disqualify carbon credit sales. However, each voluntary standard has its own additionality requirements — typically requiring that the carbon activity would not have happened without the carbon payment. If SFI already pays for cover cropping, a carbon market that credits cover-crop-derived SOC may reject additionality claims on those hectares. Specialist legal and agronomic advice is essential before committing.